Dr.
Christopher Arneson's article "Performance Anxiety: A Twenty-First Century
Perspective" discusses causes and effects of performance anxiety and
offers many techniques and ideas to overcome it. He defines performance anxiety as "a
natural reaction to situations in which we expose ourselves to judgment and
evaluation." Arising from personal
experiences and influenced by personality, performance anxiety effects us each
individually at different levels.
Arneson
presents two types of performance anxiety.
The first, trait anxiety, is "a predisposition to perceive certain
stimuli as threatening."
Individuals with this anxiety may view more situations as threatening, or
respond to threatening situations with more intense levels of state anxiety, or
both. State anxiety is
situation-specific, arising from the perception of fear, danger, and failure.
Twenty-first
century singers have increased demands; they must fly more, sing higher, be thinner,
and study faster. Increased anxiety is
often a response caused by these high expectations placed on singers today It is the voice teacher's responsibility to
recognize each student's sensitivity to anxiety, and to guide them to the
treatment they need.
Common
symptoms of performance anxiety are often physical, including shaking,
excessive sweating, and hyperventilation.
However, some may be psychological, such as worrying and fretting, the
fear of failure, and irritability before a performance. Anxiety can also cause individuals to dwell
on fantasies of catastrophes, be indecisive in their song selections, and may
even lead to depression.
Fear is a
large component to performance anxiety, and must be faced. Arneson states,
"Bringing fear into the light of conscious thought immediately weakens its
power to frighten us." He then
introduces four primary fears, from Performance
Anxiety by Eric Maisel: fear of the unexpected and unknown, fear of loss of
control, fear of strangers, and fear of love and approval. Sharing emotions can often be stressful with
loved ones, and exposure to an audience may only intensify that stress.
There are
four common therapies to overcome performance anxiety. First, behavioral therapy focuses on changing
dysfunctional behaviors that result from feeling anxious, and often
incorporates deep muscle relaxation training and desensitization. Cognitive therapy focuses on eliminating
faulty thought patterns, and cognitive-behavioral therapy is a combination of
the first two theories, aiming to change negative thought patterns and
behaviors simultaneously. The final
therapy, systematic desensitization, aims to gradually replace the response to
fear and anxiety with healthier alternatives.
Arnseson
provides twelve "Performance Anxiety Reduction (PAR) Techniques,"
including accepting and understanding your fear, silencing negative inner
voices, getting rid of excuses, and eliminating self-destructive behavior. He also encourages readers view criticism in
a healthy manner, to practice and prepare well,
release physical tension, and have realistic expectations.
Performance
anxiety can be changed, which will come from the necessary addressing of one's
fears. Arneson states, "If you show
yourself to an audience, you must be willing to take a good look at yourself
first." Be self-aware and seek
solutions to any possible sign of performance anxiety.
I like that we can supposedly just tell the voices in our head to "shut up!" I can definitely relate to this though, as i'm sure we all can. All the techniques sound like things that could work differently for different people, and that can be mixed and matched until we find what works best for us. I'm excited to try out some new techniques. Thanks Lindsey!
ReplyDeleteI know for myself, performance anxiety has always been a bit of a problem, even when I just walk into lessons. The self-doubting "voices" I once experienced whispered, "You're doing it wrong. You didn't practice enough." or even, "Just give up." were ridiculously demoralizing, but, in time, they've softened to more of an annoying drone, and simply something that I deal with by spending extra time in the practice rooms and researching my pieces even further. I still have problems, but I feel that by ignoring or through conquering, these voices, I've been able to better present the work I've done and feel better about the work myself.
ReplyDeleteAnxiety is a hard thing, and I'm glad we're learning how to help others deal with it.
This article is relatable to many situations for us as singers and for future students we may teach. For myself nerves always come in the form of physical issues such as shaky knees and hands. The coping techniques she talked about are great but this kind of stuff is easier said than done. I like what it said about being "self-aware" in order to be able to seek solutions to possible problems. Hopefully I can utilize these techniques to help myself and future students I may teach.
ReplyDeleteLindsay Burroughs
What useful information! I liked the different "personalities" in singers heads. It seems like I'm battling with at least one of those voices every time I perform. Thanks for the great summary of a very useful article!
ReplyDeleteI get a lot of performance anxiety before I sing at Juries. I am so worried that I am going to mess up the lyrics or totally forget the translations. For my "personality", I just need to make sure that I am very confident and that I shouldn't let doubt creep in and maybe that can even help make a jury better.
ReplyDeleteI really like the quote in the last paragraph of your summary about how when we present ourselves to an audience we must be willing to take a good look at ourselves. As singers we must be so confident and proud of our abilities and training when we stand up to sing a recital, and this only comes through countless hours of looking at ourselves and saying, yes I can do this. Kind of amazing that we have the capacity to do things like that.
ReplyDeletePersonally, performance anxiety is a big issue for me, which caused me forget the lyrics and running out of breath sometimes. I can tell how bad the anxiety affected on singers. However, this article was very helpful for me to understand the anxiety and how to avoid these happen.
ReplyDeleteI'm someone who has suffered from performance anxiety for a number of years now, to the point of being prescribed medication before performances. All of the points made in your summary are totally what is experienced. For a long time, I've wondered about how to make said anxiety go away. Everything that was recommended in regards to accepting that you have this fear has been the best method for me.
ReplyDeleteI'm someone who has suffered from performance anxiety for a number of years now, to the point of being prescribed medication before performances. All of the points made in your summary are totally what is experienced. For a long time, I've wondered about how to make said anxiety go away. Everything that was recommended in regards to accepting that you have this fear has been the best method for me.
ReplyDeleteI came to an interesting place with performance anxiety when I was a freshman that may or may not help you or your future students. Bear with me.
ReplyDeleteI was the student who had to do everything perfectly on the first try. If I didn't, I would beat myself up about it a lot. I was thinking about this one day when I realized that that was completely ridiculous - I was a STUDENT. If I did everything perfectly, then I wouldn't need to go to school. So I determined that in every lesson I went to with Nick, I would try whatever he asked me to, no matter how weird it sounded or looked, because realistically I had nothing to lose. Either it would work or it wouldn't, and if it didn't we'd both laugh and move on.
Then performance time would come, and I tried applying some of the same logic with one more idea - that at the moments leading up to my jury, or performance in studio, or wherever I was singing, I was as prepared as I would be for that performance. Being nervous wasn't going to make me any better than I already was (or maybe wasn't). The performance would be what it would be, and I just had to rely on my training.
In the end I've found the main fix to performance anxiety to be this: just perform for an audience as much as you can. However, that just worked for me personally as my enjoyment of the experience slowly began to eclipse my anxieties. I've come to understand that stage fright can spring from many different sources, ranging from the expected to the completely illogical, and that everyone has to find their own ways to cope with it. This may seem obvious, but I think that if you don't really love what you're doing you may never be able to effectively combat performance anxiety.
ReplyDeletethe voice of our worst critic is often very destructive, and we can easily pass it off as "constructive" or being "brutally honest." I struggle with this in my life outside of performance too and it takes a lot of effort to shutdown some of those voices!
ReplyDeleteI like the way these anxiety fixers was described. I definitely suffer from those negative inner voices, maybe telling them to keep quiet is a good place to start!
ReplyDeleteSeems to me like many of these techniques are difficult to accomplish. For example, accepting criticism with grace is easier said than done.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, something like releasing physical tension can be a good exercise.